Paneer Tikka Masala Main Dishes

Paneer Tikka Masala

A cozy, family-friendly paneer tikka masala built from a quick homemade tomato-onion sauce and a ready-made tikka masala spice mix. It keeps the deep, creamy comfort people want from takeaway night, but with a more sensible ingredient list and a gentler planetary footprint than the usual meat-heavy version.

By Lionel 12 Jun 2026 1 h 30 min total 67% in season in Northern North America · Nov 6 min read
5.0 (1 review)
Jump to recipe Save on Pinterest

Ingredients

Prepared recipes

  • Sweet Tikka Masala Spice Mix Recipe 25g Full recipe
    Preparation steps for Sweet Tikka Masala Spice Mix 2 steps 10 min
    Prep 10 min
    1. Combine the ground spices

      Add Garam Masala, Ground Cumin, Coriander Powder, Paprika, Turmeric Powder, Ground Cinnamon, Garlic Powder, Ground Black Pepper, Salt, and Brown Sugar to a dry bowl or jar. Stir or shake for 30 to 60 seconds until the color looks evenly warm orange-brown and no darker streaks of Ground Cinnamon or Turmeric Powder remain.

    2. Store it

      Store the Sweet Tikka Masala Spice Mix in an airtight container in a cool, dry place, away from direct sunlight. Use a clean, dry spoon to keep moisture out.

Make your own version Start from these ingredients in the recipe builder, swap what you like and see the nutrition per serving.

Preparation Steps

  1. Marinate the paneer

    In a bowl, combine paneer, traditional plain yogurt, about 1/3rd of the tikka masala spice mix, about half the ginger, about half the garlic, and about half the salt. Stir until the paneer is evenly coated, then let it rest in the fridge for 20 minutes so the yogurt and spice mix can season the surface and help it brown more evenly later, or let it sit in the fridge overnightif you have time.

  2. Roast the cashews and prep vegetables

    Heat your oven at 180 degrees celsius and roast your cashews for 10min. Mince the carrots, garlic, onions and ginger and cut the tomatoes in cubes.

  3. Build the masala base

    Heat most of the olive oil in a wide pan over medium heat, then add the onions ith a small pinch of salt. Cook for 8 to 10 minutes, stirring often, until the onions turn soft and lightly golden. Then add the remaining garlic, remaining ginger, and remaining tikka masala spice mix. Cook for 30 to 60 seconds, stirring, until fragrant.In another pan, cook the carrots on medium-low heat until tender.

  4. Make the homemade sauce

    Add tomatoes to the pan and stir well to coat the onions in the spiced oil. Simmer over medium-low heat for 10 to 12 minutes, stirring now and then, until the sauce thickens, darkens slightly, and the oil starts to look glossy around the edges instead of watery.

  5. Brown the paneer

    Heat the remaining olive oil in a second pan over medium-high heat and add the marinated paneer in a single layer. Cook for 4 to 6 minutes, turning carefully, until the paneer develops golden spots and the yogurt coating sets and chars lightly in places without sticking aggressively or collapsing into soft dairy rubble.

  6. Finish the tikka masala

    Lower the sauce to medium-low heat and stir in coconutmilk. Let it sit a little bit and transfer the sauce & the cashews to a blender and blend it until smooth & creamy. You then can add the browned paneer, carrots and any marinade left in the bowl. Simmer gently for 3 to 5 minutes, stirring carefully, until the paneer is heated through and the sauce becomes smooth, rich, and thick enough to coat a spoon, add a little bit of water so the sauce does not turn into a paste. Taste and add the remaining salt if needed.

  7. Serve with naan?

    Serve it hot, with rice, naan, chapati or what you have in the closet (not your gay uncle).

Recipe insights

Why paneer makes sense here

Paneer gives this dish satisfying protein and a pleasantly rich bite, so it still feels like proper comfort food rather than a sad compromise in a bowl. Compared with a more typical chicken tikka masala, leaning on dairy protein instead of meat often lowers the overall environmental footprint while keeping the texture family-friendly and familiar. If you want to push the Eat-Lancet dial a little further, the recipe also works well with firm tofu, which is frankly annoyingly practical but not as much tasty.

Why it fits the Feast On The Planet mood

This recipe sits nicely in the Eat-Lancet spirit: plant-forward, rich in aromatics, moderate in animal ingredients, and realistic for actual households with limited time and unlimited dishes. It does not demand moral purity, only a decent frying pan and a willingness to let onions soften properly. The result is a meal that feels generous, tastes indulgent, and lands a bit lighter on the planet than the meat-heavy classic. Which, in modern life, counts as a small domestic miracle.

It's a great dish overall, loved by my wife, daughter and my whole family, except some of my indians friends that find it too mild & too western. -It's not true I don't have any indian friends, yet..-

Add pulses to it

If you want to add some fibers/protein to it, you're welcome to add some chickpeas or lentils, it's always really good in a tikka/curry. I did not add anything in this recipe because we already ate our fair share of pulses today, so it'll be for next time !

Comments

Be the first to comment 👇

Recipe builder

Your recipe, measured like ours.

Pick your ingredients from our catalogue built on Health Canada’s Canadian Nutrient File, enter the grams and see the nutrition of every serving. Keep it to yourself, or share it with the community.

Example

Lentil & bulgur bowl with walnuts

4 servings · 6 ingredients

  • Green lentils, dry240 g
  • Bulgur, dry200 g
  • Baby spinach300 g
  • Cherry tomatoes300 g
  • + walnuts, olive oil70 g
Per serving
545 kcal
Protein
25 g
Fibre
16 g

Energy from

  • Protein 18%
  • Carbs 57%
  • Fat 25%

Nutrition from Health Canada · CNF 2026